Data For Use - the unpaid caregiving movement

Current practice- useful statistics

Home
Timeline of Unpaid Caregiving
Polls - what the people say
Points of View
Polite Terms- a reassessment of words we use
Current practice- useful statistics
Quotes and Links

Sadly, governments sometimes get it wrong. They are possibly misinformed. It is inaccurate to assume the number of children in a nation is the number that need daycare. It is a mistake to believe that all women who earn are not in the home or that all women who earn want or need institutiional care of their elders or children.  It is inaccurate to say that women who are not earning are not 'working'.  And when numbers of those using daycare are given, it can be misleading unless it is also pointed out how many children are not using daycare.

 

SOME USEFUL FACTS ABOUT CANADA’S TAX LAWS AND CAREGIVERS-FAMILY MEMBERS – these are the most recent numbers available. Slight variations due to updates are likely.

 

Number of children aged 6 and under (preschoolers)  -2 million

Number of children under age 15 - 6 million

Population of Canada –32 million

Number of families with children at home  - 6.7 million

            -married couples with children at home 5.7 million

            -common law couples with child at home  434,950

            -lone parent families with female head 945,000

            -lone parent families with male head  192,275

 

Observation: Children under 6 are 1/16 of the population

                           Children under 15 are 3/16 of the population

 

Birth rate in Canada – 1.07

                        Earlier rates – 1921 – 2.9                 1936 – 2.0

                                                       1945 – 3.0              1956  -2.8

                                            1966   - 1.9             1976 – 1.6

                                                       1986   - 1.4             1996  - 1.2

                                                       2000   - 1.4

                        varies per province  Nunavut 2.53, Ab 11.8

                                                NB 1.02  Ont 1.11

                        varies with incentives

                        went up in Quebec in the 1980s under generous

                        family allowance from 1.39  to 1.6

 

                        Replacement rate assumed by Canada Pension

                        Plan                           2.1

 

 

Life expectancy

                        men 75.8 years    women 81.4 years


Family size:

            3.1 persons per family

 

Marital status of those over age 14

            -single  never married 29.3%

            -married 59.7%

            -divorced 5.8%

            -widowed 6.1%

 

 

Child-rearing styles

                        -parent at home – 32% of children under age 13

                                    This number varies with age of child

                                    eg.   30% of kids 0-3, 32% of kids 3-5,

                                                37% of kids 6-9, 40% of kids 10-12

                                    36% of mothers of kids under 3 have no income

 

                        -part-time paid employment so one parent at home

                        with child more often than if full-time paid work

                                    32% of women with children

                        -grandma and relative care

                                    4% of kids aged 0-5, 17% of kids 6-9

                                    (24% of kids not with parents are with relatives)

                                    totaling 57,000 grandparents (4.5 million in US)

                        -grandparent full-time care (skip generation family)

                                    57,000 grandparents- jump of 20% since 1991

                        -parents employed full-time

                                    -31% of mothers

                        -at-home dad

                                    6% of families, 77,000 dads (up from 1,000 in

                                    1976)

                        -at-home mom

                                    1.2 million (down from 3 million in 1976)

                        -telecommuters

                                    15% of Canadians, about 1.5 million adults

                                    offered by 85% of biggest US companies

                        -job-sharing

                                    37% of US companies offer it

                        -home-based offices

                                    over one million

                        -temping

                                    tripled in last ten years

                        -self-employed women

                                    11.5% of women

                                    self-employed adults are 16% of paid labor force

                        -free sitter

                                    22% of children under age 13 use this style

                                    sometimes

                        -paid baby sitter occasional    

                                    rates vary but $11/hour is common for those

                                    sitters over 18

                        -nanny

                                    can earn up to $35,000/ year

 

                        -family dayhome

                                    21% of children aged 0-5  eg. 435,000 children

                        -daycare

                                     12% of children under 12 across Canada

                                    21% of children in Quebec

                                    (depends on age of child –eg

                                    13% of children 0-12 months, 11% aged 18-35 mos

                                    52% aged 3-6 years, 7% aged 6-12 years

                                    Observation: Only about 1/10-1/5 of the nation’s

                                    children are in daycare and of those who

                                    sometimes are, usage is high only for ages

                                    3-6 years

-amount government pays for daycare

                        -Canada - $3.5 billion a year – daycare, kindergarten

                                    and aboriginal children

                        -Saskatchewan – up to $225/month /per child subsidy

                        -Ontario – $9.7 million

                        -Quebec - $8,000 per child per year, (47.50 per day)

                        -government has operating grants and subsidizes

                        child care spaces , staff training, special needs kids

                        and gives wage subsidies all out of general revenue

                        from all citizens

                        Drs. Cleveland and Krashinsky propose a national

                        program at $5.3 billion per year

 

-payment to foster parents

                        44,600 foster children in Canada

                        -payment from government is $44 a day per child

 

-amount parents pay for daycare (much of which is deductible)

                        only 13% of households claim the deduction

                        -rates vary per arrangement and with age of

child with dayhomes costing less than institutional

care - $15/day, $160 a month

-typical costs

BC – infant $600/month, preschooler $440/month

Manitoba infant $529/month, preschooler $348/month

                        -rates also vary per province  -

                                                Nfld parent pays 80% of fees

                                                Man. parent pays 33% of fees

                                                Que parent pays 15% of fees ($7 /day)

                        -fees are not adjusted to parental income. 50%

                        of daycare users are from families in the top 30%

income bracket

 

-salary of daycare worker

                        -varies per province eg. $6 (Nfld- $13 (Ontario) per

hour

                        In 1999 Montreal workers went on strike

                                    to earn $11.41 per hour

                        -annual pay is about $20,000- while industrial

                        average salary is $34,000. Pay for same job

                        description for parent at home is zero, with

                        allowed spousal deduction of $6900

 

-adult –child ratio in daycare

                        for 3 year olds ratio is 1:7 in Nova Scotia and NB

                        for 3 year olds ratio is 1:10 in PEI and Sask

 

-income for daycares which operate for profit

                        $1.8 billion per year, of which $1.7 billion is for

                        expenses and $96 million is profit

 

-daycare staff turnover rate

                        -depends on the centre. –9.3% in Alberta in 2004

                        -has been 15% in PEI and 45% in Alberta in the past

Illustration: Helping Mom in the kitchen

daycare vacancy rates

                 - in Alberta 6,500 spaces of 26,000 are vacant

                    -in BC 62.5% spaces are vacant

 

-child dependent deduction

                        -abolished – it was at its peak $710 per child in 1984

                        In 1988 it was made a nonrefundable credit and

                        reduced to $470. In 1991 it was $69 per child

 

-child tax benefit

                        -$2500 per child under 18, ( under $7/ day)

 clawed back depending

                        on household (not caregiver) income. Clawback

                        begins at income of $32,000 and by $67,000

                        income is zero except for larger families

                        -average amount received per family $1960/yr.

                        ($5.36 per day)

                        -its per child amount is reduced in a large family

                        -at income of $120,000 it is zero unless there are

3 children per family, and then it is  $5 per child per

                        month

                        -increases are promised to $3243 by 2007

                        Can Council on Soc Development wants it $4400

                        per child

 

-national child benefit supplement

                        -only if household (not caregiver) income is under

                        $22,397

                        -maximum is $1293 per child per year($3.45/ day)

                        or $1310 for single parents, $1100 for couples

 

-family allowance

                        -discontinued. At its peak in Quebec it was $500 for

                        first child, $2500 for second child and up to $8,000

                        for third child

 

-spousal deduction (for at-home nonearning caregiver spouse)

                        -begun in 1918

                        -peaked in 1987 at $3666

                        -1950s was 1,000 when average income was $3,000

                        -$7131  though basic personal deduction is more

                                    for earning spouses at $7634

                        -spouse can only claim this deduction if income

                        is under $629 for the year, and is it reduced

                        to zero if income is $6923 per year

                        -in Alberta the two amounts are equal at $13,339

                        In NS they are equal at $7142

                        Observation: recognizing the caregiver as an

                        equal partner and a full person has been

                        an issue of contention in tax law

                        -clawbacks of this amount start with very small

                        amounts of earning

                        -Canadian Taxpayers’ Federation wants both

                        personal and spousal exemptions raised to       

                        $15,000. Conservative Alliance party proposed it be                                $10,000 each and Conservatives wanted it $12,000

each rising to 15,000

-earning styles

                        -single earner couple – 21 % of couples

                        -dual earner couples – 64% of couples

                        -single parent -

                        -single earner families – 22.7% of families

                        -dual earner families – 60.5% of families

 

marital status of parents

                        -1/5 of children are in lone-parent families

                                    (of them 1/5 are widowed, 1/5 are separated,    

                                    1/3 are divorced)

                        -by age 10, 20% of kids have seen parents break up

                                    (60% of commonlaw, 14% of married)

                        -divorce rate is 38% (up from 14% in 1969)

 

family size

                        1% of families have over 6 children (down from 20%

                        in the 1950s)

                        1/6 of Canadian children under age 14 are

                        the only children in the family

 

age of first time mother

                        33% are over 30 (up from 20% in 1987)

 

number of young adults living with parents

            67% of women aged 20-24, 74% of men aged 20-24

                       

 

-average income of couples with households with children

                        -single parent $33,374

                        -single earner family  $58,085

                        -dual earner family  $70,499

                        Observation- Single earner families have less

                        money than do dual earner families, correcting

                        common stereotype the single earner family

                        is richer

 

-tax paid on identical household income depending on earning style

 

            -on $55,000   single earner household pays $7379 tax

                                       dual earner household pays $4230 tax

            -on $100,000  single earner pays $36,643

                                       dual earner pays $25,694

 

            It depends also on style of dual-earning

            -on $60,000  single earner pays $8783

                                     -dual earner earning $30,000 and

$30,000 pays $6648

-dual earner earning $50,000 and

$10,000 pays $7959

-dual earner earning $36,000 and

$24,000 pays $9513

Observation: on equal ability to

pay there are large differences

in tax, in what is called lack of

horizontal equity

                                   

            Observation:  on identical household income single

                        earner household pays 31-66% more tax than

                        dual-earner household over the years

 

-tax paid on identical household income comparing those with children and those without

            on $80,000   - dual earner couple no kids pays $15,000

                                    -single earner couple with 3 kids pays $18,000

                        Observation:  With vastly reduced ability to pay

                        tax the single earner couple pays more tax than

                        does the dual earner couple with no children

-child care expense deduction – claimable only by dual earner

                        couples for 3party nonparental care

                        -1/4 of those who claim it are not the poor, but

                        are middle and upper income earners

                        -it is claimed by only 17% of familes

                        -$7,000 per year for child under 7 and $4,000 per

                        year for child 8-16

                        -(this amount has gone up regularly since 1976

                        when it was $2,000 for ages 0-7 and $1,000 for

                        those 8-16

                        Observation: the state assumes it costs less

                        money to raise a child the older the child is

                        Observation: the state does not recognize costs

                        of raising a child not in 3rd party care

 

-government funding of children

                        -research such as National Longitudinal Study

                                    costs $7.7 million a year

                        -setting up high-end demonstration daycares

                        and other advise programs – National Children’s

                        Agenda - $0.4 billion per year

                        -Fetal alcohol related programs $3.6 million/ year

                        -head start programs for nonparental care $46 million

                        -aboriginal daycare and mental health $101 million

                        -

 

Caregiver tax credit for the disabled

                        $3500 a year – for care of elderly ill or disabled

                        -credit of $3500 per year per disabled child (under $10

                        per day)

                        -deductions up to $10,0000 for attendant care

                        but only receipted, 3rd party non-family care

           

Pensions for homemakers

            -welcomed in 1907 by Sir Richard Cartwright

            -promised in 1984 by Tories

            -promised in 1985 by Quebec government

            -1986 Gallup poll – 82% of Canadians favor including

            homemakers in pension plan

            -39% of women but only 21% of men depend on old

                        age supplement

            13.2% of women but 26.5% of men get retirement pensions

 

cost of raising a child

`            160,000 from birth to age 19

            -in the US for low-income family $176,000 US,

            for middle-income family $238,000 US,

            for upper income family $346,000 US

 

Poverty

            1.2 million children in Canada, one in five

            -16.2% of Canadians live in poverty

            -54% of poor children live in 2 parent families

            -single parent families led b women with children

                        under 18 have poverty rate of 61.4%

            -poverty has been defined but LICO (low-income

                        cutoff), by market basket, or by basic-needs)

                        They differ on ‘poverty line’ definition from

                        $19,962 to $22.779

 

caregivers of seniors

            80% of such care is by informal family and friends unpaid

            replacement value of the 2.1 million unpaid hours is

                        over $5 billion a year

            -29% are adult daughters, 23% are wives, 12.5% are

                        husbands, 8.5% are sons, 275 are other relatives and

                        nonrelatives

 

senior care arrangements

            91% are in private homes

                        -63% are with relatives, 56% with spouse or children

                        -26% are living alone, 20% men, 6% women

 

I edit a newsletter on recent research on caregiving. It has categories of health of adult, health of child, negative effects of bad care, positive effects of good care, characteristics of caregiver, legal and political developments, feminist perspectives, international trends, national economies.  If you have anything to contribute to this research data base please write
bevgsmith@alumni.ucalgary.ca

bevgsmith@alumni.ucalgary.ca